Always the horses, seldom the jockey...
Daily Commentary on the Dallas Sports Scene - By Bob Sturm - Sportsradio 1310, The Ticket - The Athletic Dallas - The Athletic - Bob Sturm
If you are wondering, the answer is Nov. 11, 1966.
Fifty-one years ago and some change is how long it had been since the Dallas Cowboys managed to lose a game to an opponent that produced as little offense as the Seahawks did Sunday, when they took a vital game with high stakes after generating just 136 yards of total offense.
I was wrong in assuming it had never happened before in Cowboys history. Just not in my lifetime. But evidently, it happened twice in the 1960s. And the most recent time -- that day 51 years ago -- was a day in which the Eagles beat the Cowboys 24-23 and generated all of their points off three special teams plays. Two Timmy Brown kickoff returns and Aaron Martin's punt return accounted for all three of the Eagles' touchdowns and overcame the fact that the Eagles had 80 total yards of offense as they took down Don Meredith and the Cowboys.
But if you are asking if it had ever happened in a Dallas Cowboys home game, the answer is no. Before Sunday, the Cowboys had never lost a game in which their defense had allowed so few as 136 yards. For that previous record, you had to go all the way back to 1961, when the St. Louis Cardinals took the win in the Cotton Bowl against your Cowboys with 193 yards of offense, two Bill Stacy interception returns for touchdowns and the aid of five Cowboys turnovers from Eddie LeBaron and friends.
That is how rare Sunday's result was.
The Cowboys defense allowed very little. Here is a look at what should be a victorious defensive drive chart:
As you can see, the Seahawks did put together two successful drives -- both started by Cowboys turnovers -- that were taken into the end zone. Add to that a third touchdown on the Dak Prescott pick-six, and you see how the Seahawks won something rather uncommon: a game in which their offense did not move the ball all day long. But in games where they are minus-3 in the turnover battle, the Cowboys lose almost every time (as would everyone else). The Cowboys are now 11-113 in games all-time when they take a minus-3 in the turnover battle. Can't do that and survive.
... Which leads us to the actual issues of Sunday for the defense. If you are going to choose between giving up yardage or taking the ball away, we certainly know the correlation stats. Takeaways are how a team wins football games. Yardage is generally just yardage. And while we properly place most of the blame on the offense for the way the season has deteriorated, we should take careful note of this defense not generating any takeaways for the fifth time this season. That doesn't lead the league -- Miami has actually had seven games with no takeaways -- but it has led to losses. As a league, regardless of any other factor (quality of the opponent, site of the game, etc.), teams win just 26 percent of the games in which they generate zero takeaways. The Cowboys, now 1-4 in those games (they beat Arizona), are at 20 percent.
WEEKLY DATA BOX
It certainly takes the analysis out of an analysis piece to surmise that you reached just about every objective you would like in a game like this, but people, let's be reasonable here. No team is supposed to lose a game in which the defense allowed 2.5 yards per play. That is just insane. The Seahawks are a very poor offensive team -- no doubt about it -- but this is the NFL, and they have Russell Wilson. You limited them to one drive of substance, one play of 20 yards and sacked Wilson three times. And you still lost.
Defensive reasons for losing? Well, the red-zone defense allowed two touchdowns in two opportunities and you never got a takeaway. Otherwise, there isn't too much to complain about.
RUSSELL WILSON THROW CHART
You would be hard-pressed to play Wilson much better than this. He is a dangerous playmaker who has speedy weapons that can cause issues, for sure. And the Cowboys limited him almost totally. Almost. He will take shots down the field, but there was almost nothing in this game.
EXPLOSIVES ALLOWED
SPLASH PLAYS - VS. SEATTLE
SPLASH PLAYS - SEASON TOTALS
Again, it was the Cowboys defense in a bit of a nutshell. It played well. It played fine. But it didn't generate a play to win the game and, by anyone's measure, was the second-best defense on the field Sunday. It plays hard, it gets things accomplished, it could be worse ... But in the end, it is a defensive unit that is middle-of-the-road. That worked well when the offense was top five. But middle-of-the-road offense and middle-of-the-road defense means a season around 8-8.
And here we are.
Let's check a few videos:
I think Taco Charlton can feel good about the finish to his rookie season. More and more as the year has gone along, he has started to show up a bit more and there are signs that he has a future. I know opinions are all in ink and I definitely had views on draft weekend about the Cowboys taking him, but since he has been here, I have no real issues with his attitude or tools to develop. I think in Year 3, he has a chance to be pretty nice. This shows his size and his power. He closes Wilson down on a four-man pressure that brings a linebacker and drops Maliek Collins into a spy role. Charlton now has three sacks, and we can be optimistic that he can make a run at 6-8 next season.
Here is the "Deacon" package on third down -- three rushers and one linebacker spy who delays his rush. On this, Benson Mayowa gets left tackle Duane Brown nicely. That requires some real strength to grasp on and bring him down in that frenzy, and he made it look easy. Mayowa has just this one sack after six last season, but I still really like his flashes that have drawn multiple holding penalties and caused other plays despite not getting the sacks.
Here is the fantastic sack by DeMarcus Lawrence on Sunday that demonstrates he was not an early-season fluke. He now has 14.5 sacks on the season (admittedly, September and October were his best work), which likely says he has received much more attention as the season has gone along and that it would have been nice to have had David Irving play more this season. Regardless, he is just a half-sack behind the league lead and I bet a sack title would cap off his fine pre-free agency season.
I don't know what your first reaction was when Lawrence ran down Wilson, but this was mine:
Now, that is an obvious reference to some and a confusing tweet to others. So, let's let everyone in on the fun. Here is the Bob Griese sack by Bob Lilly in Super Bowl VI (the very rare Bob-on-Bob sack):
They still haven't posted the All-22 from Super Bowl VI, but it does show you that even with all of this time passing, quarterbacks running backward to try to keep a play alive often goes very poorly.
Now, those two red-zone touchdowns were a big story, so let's view them.
This is Jimmy Graham. He is 6-foot-7, 265 pounds. Jourdan Lewis will try to cover him. He is 5-10, 188. How did you think this was going to go? On the goal line, they are trying pre-snap motion to see if they can get this matchup or if Byron Jones will follow him (which causes its own issues and may not fare considerably better). This is their Dez Bryant fade, but it is even more of a sure thing. If you have a big target on a tiny defender, this is a pretty easy decision for your quarterback to make.
Look at the Cowboys trying to sort through this after the motion. Wilson is thinking, "Are they serious? They are leaving their 5-10 corner out there against him?"
Second and goal from the 6-yard line. This is where you really needed to force a field goal if possible. You can see the Cowboys are going to double Graham here and the Seahawks are going to isolate a rub route to where they find individual coverage. Red-zone defense is really difficult if they have a Graham, because either you double him or you don't. And either decision is going to be wrong because the Seahawks have seen it all. This time, they use Doug Baldwin to the corner and Chidobe Awuzie gets caught sitting on the slant (it appears). Touchdown.
Next week, we finish up 2017. For now, let's put this Seattle game to bed and turn the page.
Dallas Cowboys offensive guard Chaz Green (79) tries to keep Atlanta Falcons defensive end Adrian Clayborn (99) from tackling Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott (4) in the second quarter at Mercedes-Benz Stadium in Atlanta, Georgia, Sunday, November 12, 2017. Zak escaped the attack. (Tom Fox/The Dallas Morning News)
Decoding Linehan
The Atlanta Falcons started Week 10 with the 18th-ranked pass rush in the NFL with 18 sacks. They were closer to the bottom of the league (Tampa Bay, 8) than they were to the top, where Jacksonville sits with 35. By nightfall, they were tied for No. 7 and are now just three sacks out of second place.
Meanwhile, the Cowboys' offensive line trailed only the New Orleans Saints in protecting its quarterback. Drew Brees had been sacked eight times in 2017, with Dak Prescott at 10. The Cowboys' pass protection again had been one of the very best in the NFL. But, by the time they boarded their plane to head back to Dallas, the Cowboys had fallen behind Minnesota, Pittsburgh, the Los Angeles Chargers and Rams, Oakland, Jacksonville, Atlanta and Miami, all the way down to No. 10 in sacks surrendered.
It is very possible that by Tuesday, you don't want to think about the battering Prescott was forced to withstand in Atlanta, but the historical significance of what occurred Sunday compels us to make sure we record it in this "Decoding Linehan" space for future reference. No matter how bad things get for certain teams and players, it will likely not compare negatively to what the Falcons' front did to the Cowboys' offensive line.
Everyone took losses on snaps. Even the normally perfect Zack Martin gave up a rare sack. Travis Frederick was tossed aside disrespectfully a few times by Falcons defensive tackles. But the complete disaster at the left tackle position is where this game will rest upon. And rightfully so.
The only positive to take from the offensive performance as a whole is that it appears the quarterback is somehow no worse for wear. He might be bruised and sore, but it appears his currently durable body was able to endure this complete disaster. Teams get beat all the time in this league, but once you lose your QB1 for two months, the party is over. The Cowboys flirted with that disaster continuously (and needlessly a few times), but they still have a healthy quarterback. I will not undersell that.
Beyond that, what we do today is merely marvel at how a rather average defensive end with a rather average career destroyed the Cowboys' left tackle position in a way we may never see again.
Let's hope so, anyway.
WEEKLY DATA BOX
Not a lot of good up there. Less than 4 yards per play! Just two trips to the red zone, and on one of those they took the ball at the 21! Seven points and 233 yards! All just awful.
Drive-killers will ruin your team. We consider "drive-killers" anything that brings your effort to a grinding halt. The most egregious of these will always be the sack -- you lose your down and you get your quarterback hit -- with holding being a slightly less penal version of it. With holding, you at least repeat the down and generally spare your quarterback the violence. But both effectively end the drive at a better-than-80-percent clip.
What makes the Cowboys' offense so impressive is that it avoids these as well as any offense in the sport. Through the first eight games, the Cowboys' offense had 85 drives, and of those 85, only four suffered actual drive-killers (all from sacks). They had given up other sacks and other holds, but to their credit had been able to survive them each time.
But Sunday was a different deal altogether. They suffered eight drive-killers in one game -- on only 10 drives! So, Games 1-8: 85 drives, four killed. Game 9: 10 drives, eight killed by sacks and/or penalties (pretty much all sacks).
I am willing to bet we won't see Chaz Green at left tackle again. I don't mean to be too difficult on the young man who is already taking heat from enough directions, but in professional sports, there is a bar you must reach each week or you are discarded and replaced rather quickly. He quite clearly did not come close to reaching it. Were there some mitigating circumstances we are unaware of? Perhaps. But either way, Tyron Smith is one of the best in the league and when he misses a game because his body cannot answer the bell, the Cowboys have to still be functional. They were not. Not even close.
The chart below shows the team's weekly ability to "stay ahead of the chains." Obviously, you want to -- ideally -- knock out a chunk on first down so you are around 7 yards on second down and a shorter distance on third down (5-6 yards to go is a fine average). If, like Sunday, your red line is longer than your blue line, you are going backward, and that means you are having some significant offensive issues.
The very good news is that most weeks, the Cowboys are in a good position. Weeks 4-9 have been really impressive. But according to this visual aid, we can confirm yet again that Sunday was horrendous.
DAK PRESCOTT THROW CHART
I know this is a fun time to run with your Prescott narratives, National Hot Take Guy, but honestly, all Sunday showed me is that the Cowboys have a warrior playing quarterback. The less time you have to throw, the shorter the throws have to be because nobody has a chance to run a route. This will not tell you took much beyond some colorful dots on a black screen.
PERSONNEL GROUPINGS
The above chart is called, "Hey, Scott Linehan, did you notice every time you ran the ball out of 13 or 22 Personnel, you were getting 8 yards a carry?" Also, why did you only do it six times when they didn't show the ability to stop it? If Joseph Randle was here, he would point out how much meat was left on that bone.
*****
OK, well, it is time to look at the tape. I just want to warn you in case you can't bear to deal with it: This will not feature much positivity.
We shall call the following portion, "Tyron Smith Appreciation."
First drive: This is a second-and-9 at the Falcons' 37. The Falcons are going to run a five-man pressure with a sixth man (No. 45, Deion Jones) as a trail blitzer who allows those in front of him to slant toward the right. Jones then fills the trail lane on the left, which is where Prescott would look to escape. It works very well for Atlanta as one of its go-to attacks. But as you can see, Green gives up the left tackle flank to Clayborn too easily, and this is the first of many sacks. Clayborn is wide, Green can't move his feet and carry his weight back there, his head drops, and it is over. Green almost tipped over. There is no way you can stop a train with that balance.
Third drive: third and 8. Fire zone blitz, where Clayborn is not even a rusher. He drops as the opposite defensive end on a fire zone with five rushers, becoming one of two zone defenders in the hook/curl area near the sticks. The Cowboys run this blitz a ton, too. Green gives up his corner to No. 97, Grady Jarrett, so Prescott steps up and looks to take off. Clayborn does not miss him in space and gets a poacher sack.
Fourth drive: This is a third-and-9. A basic four-man rush. This is the extremely rare moment when Martin gets beat on pass protection for a sack by Dontari Poe. Poe is a very impressive athlete and Martin was knocked off balance, then could not recover. I believe that was the first time he was physically beaten for a sack since 2015. Rare, indeed.
Fifth drive: Two-minute drill in first half. This is not a sack. This is your quarterback saving your left tackle from giving up another one. Clayborn is killing Green with one move. One. All day. The same under move where he gets his inside shoulder outside of your outside shoulder. You can see Green trying to cheat the snap because he just physically can't get to his spot in time. His head drops, he is off balance and has no strength at that point. When we talk about feet and quickness in draft season, this is what we are talking about. To be a tackle, you need a lot of attributes -- but if you cannot move your feet, you have no chance.
The next play: The Cowboys give Rod Smith the chip and it works. But La'el Collins loses on his side to Vic Beasley after Prescott finds nothing open, so he runs for his life again and actually gets 2 yards before taking another hit.
This is three plays later. Prescott can no longer breathe because he is so exhausted from running. Now Brooks Reed is charging at Green, and Green takes a holding penalty. Prescott puts a nice throw on Cole Beasley to put Dallas in a position to tie the game at 10-10 with a half-ending field goal, but they march it back because of the hold.
The half ends three plays later when Prescott is taken down again, because Green has to either hold Clayborn on the weird spin move or give up the sack. He pretty much does both, the ball gets away and the Falcons recover to end this drive.
"The coaches did him no favors. You can't hide a left tackle, but you can help him. In the third quarter, the Cowboys are still in the game. They take their first drive of that quarter right down the field with great power on the ground. Down just 17-7 with much of the second half to play, they marched all the way to the Falcons' 12-yard line after Alfred Morris had runs of 14 yards, 20 yards, and 11 yards. They have actually salvaged the situation and now have a first down in the red zone. Why then, Mr. Linehan, would you decide to hop back into shotgun on first down and ask Chaz Green to pass protect -- on an island -- against a guy who already has four sacks against him? It is first down and your offensive line and power personnel groupings had just mowed all the way down the field in a few short plays. And now, you want to take those tight ends off the field and get back into shotgun on first down? Predictably, the play ended in a sack and that drive was killed, too. In fact, when Mike Nugent even missed the chip-shot 38-yard field goal, the game effectively ended."
The same exact move from Clayborn.
Fourth quarter -- seventh drive. This is the one that made Troy Aikman lose his mind. So, they have help for Green here. His only job is not to get beat outside, because Cooper is there to help him inside. I don't want to say this is 7th-grade stuff here, but it is. You simply cannot let him get your outside shoulder -- no matter what.
He got beat to the outside. So frustrating. This is where they got the hook out for him.
So, this is drive No. 8 -- Byron Bell has a chance. And on fourth and 6, he takes the holding penalty and gives up a sack to Reed on the same play.
And finally, the play I think Jason Garrett should be happy didn't get his quarterback hurt. Again, back to yesterday:
"Even though the game was over in the fourth quarter (after a few more sacks), the staff that evidently had their brains suspended for the game are calling timeouts down 27-7 to try to get the ball back so they can call more plays in shotgun and get their star QB blindsided a few more times by Clayborn and friends, who have savaged the left tackle spot long after Chaz Green was gone and Byron Bell (their other idea) was being served up on a platter.
"They should have been running the ball or even taking a knee -- not calling timeouts to prolong the destruction -- but Jason Garrett is going to never stop being Jason Garrett. They never really helped out Chaz Green, nor did they modify their strategies to protect him from getting Dak killed, but instead wanted to get the ball back to rerun their same poor strategies. Madness."
Clayborn. Same move. The same exact move. You know why? He doesn't have more than one move.
The Cowboys realized just how good Tyron Smith is Sunday. They hadn't experienced a day like this in decades. Let's hope they go decades before it happens again.
